Posts filed under Pen Reviews

Waldmann Précieux Fountain Pen Review

Founded in 1918, Waldmann is a well-loved and respected German stationery maker. Known for their classic styles and use of Sterling Silver in their high-end models, this brand has only come into my purview in the past year as they made a push into the US market.

Waldmann’s US distributor, Luxury Brands, sent me several pens to check out, and the Précieux immediately stood out among the group. The style, design, feel, and look of the pen are all right up my alley. But before I break it all down, I want to quickly discuss my review process as it relates to this pen, because I’ve found it to be especially challenging.

Objective: Not influenced by personal feelings or opinions in considering or representing facts.

Subjective: Based on or influenced by personal feelings, tastes, or opinions.

When reviewing products, I think I do a good job on both sides of the objective/subjective ledger. That said, I believe in having an opinion at the end of the day. The difficult thing is that it is just that: One persons opinion. I’m fortunate that people find my opinions valuable, and I’m going to keep giving my opinions. But sometimes, like in the case of the Waldmann Précieux, the subjective butts up against the objective in a challenging way.

Objectively, the Précieux is a great pen. Waldmann’s build quality is exceptional. The metal barrel is well-balanced and comfortable to use. The 18k gold nib - manufactured for Waldmann by Bock - is tuned perfectly for writing right out of the box. It’s all-around enjoyable to use, and beautiful to look at. If I was forced to put down a negative, the only one I could come up with is that it feels priced a little high. Not outrageously high by any stretch, but there is a ton of competition in the $400 price range.

Subjectively, I’m finding it difficult to come up with any reason to own this pen myself. On the surface, it falls into the Cross, Parker, Sheaffer, and Waterman category: Safe, trusted brands. Brands that just work. Also, brands that make products I rarely find compelling, despite how nice the end result is.

The Précieux wasn’t the only Waldmann pen I was able to take a look at. I was sent the Tuscany, Commander, and Xetra models as well. And while the Précieux jumped out of the box in relation to the rest of the group (I guess I have expensive tastes!) the rest of these are just as nice. In fact, I think the Tuscany in Rose Gold is the best looking of the bunch, and for just over $200 with a steel nib, makes a more compelling buying argument.

(Sidebar: Why do companies not include converters with the purchase of a pen? I don’t care if the selling price is $20 or $2000, the manufacturer cost for a converter is minuscule, and the benefit and goodwill it offers with inclusion far outstrips the cost. The Précieux only comes with a converter because it is integrated in the design of the pen. The others don’t.)

Waldmann makes good pens. Their designs are eye-catching in a classic sense, and they have 100 years of production behind them. There is clearly a market there, even though I may not be rushing to pick one up for myself. If you like the look of their pens, I think you will be happy with your purchase. They are very well made. Personally, I am interested in what they are doing on the ballpoint and pencil side of the ledger, and may look at exploring those next and seeing what else this brand has to offer.

For further reading, JetPens has a lengthy interview with Stefan Schnirch, CEO of Waldmann, and also carries a wide range of Waldmann ballpoint and fountain pens.

(Luxury Brands loaned this product to The Pen Addict for review purposes.)

Enjoy reading The Pen Addict? Then consider becoming a member to receive additional weekly content, giveaways, and discounts in The Pen Addict shop. Plus, you support me and the site directly, for which I am very grateful.

Membership starts at just $5/month, with a discounted annual option available. To find out more about membership click here and join us!

Posted on November 4, 2019 by Brad Dowdy and filed under Waldmann, Fountain Pens, Pen Reviews.

Tactile Turn Gist Delrin Fountain Pen Review

(Jeff Abbott is a regular contributor at The Pen Addict. You can find more from Jeff online at Draft Evolution and Twitter.)

Back in 2015, I reviewed the second generation of Tactile Turn's retractable pen — the Mover. I was enamored with that pen and loved carrying it around with me on my day-to-day errands and office work. I don't carry it around quite as much today, but my fondness for the pen hasn't changed at all. Recently, I was given the opportunity to try out a new version of Tactile Turn's popular Gist fountain pen. The Black and White Delrin fountain pen is a beauty, and it still manages to capture some of that early magic that I enjoyed so much with the Mover.

So, what is Delrin? My incredibly simplistic definition likely won't do it the full justice it deserves, but Delrin is a brand name of synthetic polymer thermoplastic material. It's incredibly lightweight while also being very durable and rigid. According to many machinists, it's a fantastic material for learning and practicing the art of turning pens due to being more cost effective and forgiving than other materials. Aside from that, it's also a really cool material that has a unique aesthetic and great performance. If you ever hold a pen made from Delrin, you might catch yourself thinking that it feels a lot like a Lamy 2000. And, you wouldn't be entirely wrong. The Lamy 2000 is made of Makrolon — another name brand thermoplastic polymer. While they aren't chemically identical, they're similar enough to share the same benefits and general characteristics.

Compared to metal, plastics are a lot lighter. The aluminum, copper, and brass versions of the Gist are a good deal heavier than the Delrin version, but that doesn't mean the Delrin version is brittle, cheap, or disposable. We're not talking about the plastic material used in a Pilot G2 or Bic — Delrin (and other similar materials) are extremely durable, rigid, and strong. You can put this pen through a lot of abuse and it will just keep on working. Over time, it also develops a unique look. And, being a Tactile Turn pen, the Gist also has the characteristic grooves all along the cap, barrel, and grip section, adding extra grip that I really appreciate.

The Gist isn't a new pen by any means, but this new material and color combination is phenomenal. The creamy white matched up with the black trim is enticing, and it reminds me of a stormtrooper uniform. The cap and barrel are both slightly transparent, allowing some of the light to pass through if there's nothing inside the pen. In the cap, you can see where the grip section ends and the nib begins. In the body, you can see where the converter or the cartridge ends. I think it's great - something between a solid and demonstrator.

On the color combination I have, the grip section, the clip, and the finial are all black. The clip is metal, but everything is made of the same Delrin material. The contrast is great, but I recognize that not everyone will agree. And that's fine because there are other options. In Delrin, you can also choose a completely white model or a completely black model. With any Gist you purchase, you have the option of picking a black or silver clip. If you're not into the Delrin material, you can also choose from titanium, copper, or brass. And, if you're not a fountain pen fan, you can also pick any of these up in the rollerball configuration. You can browse all the different materials and colors on their website.

After uncapping the pen, you're greeted with a really well-balanced pen. The black section marries perfectly to the body, and the long #6 nib has just the right length to compliment the other components.

The section accepts either short international cartridges or an international converter. Keep in mind that longer or wider converters will not fit in this body, so just stick with the converter that comes with the pen.

After inking up the pen, I was excited to try out this titanium nib. I've used titanium nibs before, but never in a pen that I've been able to use for more than a few minutes. While I will say that the writing experience has been great, it was a bit disappointing that this nib writes like a medium instead of extra fine imprinted on the nib. I have nothing against medium nibs, but it's not what was advertised. That being said, I really like this nib and I've also decided that I'll probably go for a titanium nib any time I have the option. It's a lightweight and flexible material and has a great amount of tactile feedback that is similar to a steel nib. To me, this titanium nib is the perfect marriage of what I love about steel and gold nibs. Gold nibs are soft and flexible, while steel nibs have a more rigid stance and provide greater feedback from the page. The soft tactility of the titanium nib is fantastic.

The nib is fairly wet, but that's how I prefer wider nibs. And, given the soft nature of the material, it's also fairly easy to create some line variation if you apply a small amount of pressure on the down-strokes.

Writing with the pen is extremely comfortable. The grip section is long enough to provide plenty of space for my fingers and the way I hold the pen, and the threads that hold the cap are flat on top, meaning they don't irritate my fingers when they rest on the threads for longer periods of time. The length of the uncapped pen is perfect for my hand, but writing with the cap posted is also perfectly comfortable.

One area that I have complained when using this pen is opening and closing the cap. The unique threads are solid in operation, but the beginning and end of the threads aren't as sure-footed as I'd like. Threading the cap onto the body can feel a little mushy at times, and the same is true when I tighten the cap to the end of the threads. When tightening to the end, there isn't a distinguished feeling that I've reached the end of the threads. Sure, it gets tighter and requires more pressure, but I don't feel like I've ever reached the end of the road. On the other end, I feel like I sometimes have to fish around a bit for the threads to really grip correctly when I place the cap on the pen to close it. These are minor complaints, but they're worth pointing out. Keep in mind that I'm only using a single copy of the Gist for this review. This may be a very isolated issue that doesn't affect others.

Finally, when it comes down to price, the Gist is priced very fairly for a machined pen from a small shop. The Delrin pens start at $99. This price includes a steel nib in either EF, F, M, or B size and either a silver or black clip. For $60 more, you can choose from the same list of nib sizes but in titanium. If you opt for the brass, copper, or titanium materials, the price goes up accordingly.

The Tactile Turn Gist is a pen that I quickly fell in love with after using it for a few minutes. Despite the mislabeled nib, I love how this pen writes and how it feels in my hand while writing and even while capped. The Delrin material is incredibly rigid but has a familiar warmth that makes it fun to use. If it's in your price range and you like the aesthetic, I can't recommend this pen enough.

(JetPens provided this product at no charge to The Pen Addict for review purposes.)

Membership starts at just $5/month, with a discounted annual option available. To find out more about membership click here and join us!

Posted on October 30, 2019 by Jeff Abbott and filed under Tactile Turn, Fountain Pens, Pen Reviews.

Lamy ST Tri Multi Pen Review

(JetPens provided this product at no charge to The Pen Addict for review purposes.)

There's been a lot of multi pens cross my desk over the past several years, but I'm still so fascinated by the utilitarian function of this pen genre. It's also fun to see how different manufacturers tackle different design and usability problems to make their offerings competitive. Most of all, these multi pens mostly drum up a healthy dose of nostalgia.

At the end of the day, these things all cost money and essentially do the same thing. Choosing the right one (since "all of them" isn't usually an acceptable response) can be difficult, but you can easily narrow down the options by knowing what you like. Personally, I really like the click tab method of selecting a color over the rotating selector. One of the coolest method is the gravity selector, which means that you select different refills by rotating the pen in your hand until the correct color is pointing up, then click the nock to extend that refill. Another major factor to consider is price. Multi pens can range quite a bit in price, and the new pen we're looking at today definitely falls into the higher range. The Lamy ST Tri multi pen is a stainless body that features two ballpoint refills and one 0.5mm mechanical pencil component. The model featured here ships with a black ballpoint and an orange fluorescent refill (meant for highlighting), but the orange refill in my unit was nonoperational from the get-go.

If you've ever shopped for multi pens before, you've probably come across the Zebra Sharbo X line, which is one of the more expensive options out there. The price relates directly to the materials and quality of the build, which is spot on with the Sharbo X. But the Lamy ST multi pen is here to possibly shake that up.

The Lamy ST is a well-built multi pen that's made out of stainless steel. Available in a couple of different colors and finishes, the ST is a premium pen with two refill slots and a mechanical pencil component. Similar to the Sharbo, you select different refills by twisting the grip section. The Lamy requires a firm pressure, but there's a satisfying chunk whenever the refill is extended completely to let you know it's ready to write. As you'd expect, the button on the top of the pen allows you to extend and retract the lead in the pencil component. A nice touch here is that the button is disabled when you don't have the mechanical pencil extended. Also, there's a tiny eraser hidden under the button cap in case you need to erase tiny mistakes.

The ring that separates the grip section from the main body of the pen has three color indicators to let you know which way to turn to use a specific color. I don't like that Lamy took this approach since I might decide to use purple and green refills instead of the black and orange that is included with the pen. I much prefer a generic label or no label at all versus permanent colors. With a pen that costs more than $50, it's a little disappointing to see that this choice persisted through the design and evaluation phases at Lamy headquarters.

The grip section is really comfortable as long as your hands aren't sweating. The smooth stainless steel grip can get a little shifty at times. There's a small grip pattern etched into the grip, but it's not pronounced enough to offer any additional grip over the bare metal. If the etching was just a bit deeper or wider, it would be perfect.

Like most multi pens, the ST is fairly long. This extra length adds stability and favorable balance when writing, but I wish Lamy made the choice to shorten the pen just a tad. This is a personal preference of mine — I would prefer the pen be more stow-able instead of longer for writing comfort. The steel body is begging to be used as a daily carry that can stand up to the test of time.

At the top of the pen, there's also a clip. Before now, I've never met a Lamy clip that I didn't like. The clip on this ST is weak and moves around quite a bit. The ring that holds the clip in place has a small 0.5mm gap that allows the clip to move back and forth in its slot. This doesn't drive me crazy, but it definitely annoys me due to the price point. The clip does its job as long as the pen doesn't get turned upside down.

Writing with the ST is comfortable, but let's talk about the included refills that Lamy packs in this pen. They're not good. The black medium tip refill is smooth, but it requires too much pressure to write. Plus, the ink isn't bold or crisp. The line is a murky dark gray that seems to second-guess itself at every turn. The orange highlight is a cool idea, but I really don't know if it holds up against the marketing since my unit refuses to write. I was looking forward to trying it out to see how transparent it is and how effective it is at calling out things on the page. Oh well — maybe next time. The mechanical pencil works flawlessly.

The factor refills aren't great, but don't despair yet! These are standard D1 refills, so you can swap them out for a plethora of different colors and tip sizes. Buying a few extra refills to customize your multi pen is something I recommend very heartily, but it's disappointing that Lamy chose mediocre refills as the standard on this pricey multi pen. On the flip-side, the Zebra Sharbo X line don't come with any refills out of the box, so it's a nice gesture.

Apart from the stainless steel model featured in this review, you also have a choice of a matte black steel finish or a brushed stainless steel finish. The brushed finish costs a few dollars extra, but it's entirely worth it for the reason that you get a classic Lamy clip instead of the lackluster clip found on the stainless steel versions. Aside from the clip, the brushed finish just looks incredible. Again, this comes down to personal preference, but I think there's a clear winner here in terms of aesthetics.

It may sound like I'm being hard on the Lamy ST, and you're right. It's a decent multi pen that performs well. A few nags aside, it's a great option for a daily multi pen that you carry everywhere. It will certainly stand the test of time, and the fact that it uses standard D1 refills means you'll be able to customize it and easily buy replacement refills when you run out of ink. The bottom line is that this pen doesn't feel like a $70 item. If it were closer to $40, I would recommend it quickly. At $70, I feel like you get a lot more value out of the Zebra Sharbo X line, or even the top end of the Pilot/Uni/Zebra/Pentel/Sakura lines.

If you take one look at the Lamy ST and know that it fits a certain niche in your pen collection, then go for it. It's built well and will be a great pen. If you're interested in finding a premium multi pen made of metal, start elsewhere. You'll save a few bucks that you can spend on extra refill colors and tip sizes!

(JetPens provided this product at no charge to The Pen Addict for review purposes.)

Membership starts at just $5/month, with a discounted annual option available. To find out more about membership click here and join us!