Posts filed under Fountain Pens

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue with Elastic Nib: A Review

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue with Elastic Nib: A Review

(Susan M. Pigott is a fountain pen collector, pen and paperholic, photographer, and professor. You can find more from Susan on her blog Scribalishess.)

Ahhhh. Nakayas. Nobody warned me that buying one Nakaya would lead to buying another and another and another. I honestly thought I might own one or two at most because they are freaking expensive. But then I scroll through the Nakaya listings at Nibs.com, swallow hard, contemplate the beauty, and rationalize why I must have another one.

The Nakaya Shinobu in blue is a pen I've coveted for a long time. I was entranced by the fern pattern carved delicately into the ebonite. One evening, depressed over signing my terminal contract as a professor, I pressed the "buy" button on the Shinobu at Nibs.com. The next day, remorseful, I sent an email, requesting that they cancel my order. But during the pandemic, no one was monitoring emails, and two days later, I received confirmation that my pen with its special elastic nib was ready to ship. What's a girl to do--send it back? Are you kidding???

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue with Elastic Nib

All Nakayas come in a softwood box lined in red velveteen and wrapped in a pen kimono.

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue with Elastic Nib Packaging

When I removed the Shinobu from its kimono, I gasped, stunned, as always, by the craftsmanship and beauty. I took the pen into our Florida Room to see it in sunlight. It glows as if it were lit from within.

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue

The base color of the pen is black urushi. Nibs.com describes the crafting process:

Many stages go into making the special surface of this pen. First layers of urushi lacquer are applied over the natural hard rubber. Then the pattern is hand engraved into these layers followed by an application of blue pigment, first applied then removed leaving traces in the carved crevices.

Look at the exquisite details:

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue Barrel
Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue Cap Detail
Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue Close up

Even the grip is carved:

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue Grip

I was excited to find the Shinobu in the Neo Standard, a model I did not yet own. The Neo Standard is lightly tapered at both ends, and the barrel has a subtle curve.

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue Shape

This is a medium-sized pen, measuring 5.9 inches/150 mm capped and 5.3 inches/135mm uncapped. You cannot post the cap. Although the barrel at its widest is about 15 mm, the grip is only 10 mm. Ebonite pens are not heavy. The Neo Standard weighs 24 grams capped and 20.5 grams uncapped and inked. The pen is perfectly balanced in the hand.

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue Uncapped

I chose a medium soft, two-toned nib and requested the elastic modification. An elastic nib is created by cutting out notches on each side of the nib. This customization gives the nib a bounciness similar to a paintbrush. It lends the nib some line variation, but not as much as a flex nib.

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue Nib
Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue Elastic Nib

Out of all the different nib styles, the elastic nib is my absolute favorite. It is like writing with a paintbrush, but with much more control. The nib makes writing soothing and pleasurable. It's meditation with a pen!

Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue Writing
Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu Blue Writing Close Up

The base price for a Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu in blue is $1,800. Yup. This baby is expensive. You will pay more for a two-toned vs. single-toned nib, and the elastic modification adds $100 to the total (_so_ worth it!)

I was lucky that Nibs.com had this pen in stock when I decided to click "buy." A pen like this can take twelve or more months to arrive if it is not in stock. I promise that it's worth the wait, though!

(I purchased this Nakaya Neo Standard Shinobu in blue with my own funds.)

Posted on July 17, 2020 and filed under Nakaya, Fountain Pens, Pen Reviews.

Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen Review

Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen Review

The Kaweco Supra is one of those products I am happy exists, but I am unsure how it fits into my day to day use of fountain pens.

The Supra is a modular pen, meaning it is built to be taken apart and configured to fit your preferred writing style. It can be a full length, metal barrel, postable cap, standard converter fountain pen, or it can be a shorter, pocketable, short cartridge, EDC-type fountain pen.

Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen

I love having all of this choice, but in the case of the Supra, I wonder if it is too much.

My preferred build of the Supra is the shortest build, with the center barrel section removed. In this configuration, it looks like a supersize Kaweco Liliput. Maybe that’s where the name comes from? Who knows, but this is a great setup. It allows for a shorter, more portable pen, with the benefit of the larger #6 sized nib. When posted, like the Liliput or any Kaweco Sport model, it turns into a full-length writer.

Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen Barrel
Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen Comparison

One issue I’m having with the Supra - which is common with metal-barrel pens - is that the threads are very sharp. My fingers often land on the threads at the top end of the section where the cap screws on. The sharpness of those threads is noticeable. Maybe with repeated use the edge gets knocked off, but right now I have to adjust my grip to stay clear.

Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen Long
Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen Posted

The long-barrel setup of the Supra is an interesting one. It bulks up the pen with the barrel section in place and turns it into more of a desk pen. It’s definitely heavy in this scenario, but usable. Just don’t consider posting the cap on the end of the barrel unless you are looking for a post-workout cool down session.

Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen vs Liliput
Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Liliput

Number 6 nibs aren’t the norm for most Kaweco’s and I appreciate the decision to build around it for the Supra. The downside is that the nib performance itself isn’t good. Kaweco’s nib manufacturing has been a source of conversation for years: Are they Bock? Are they Jowo? Are they Kaweco? The best answer I’ve been able to get is that their nibs are a combination of all of the above.

Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen Nib

Kaweco used the Bock factory in the past, and now uses the Jowo factory, to make Kaweco’s own proprietary nib and feed design. Once plagued with inconsistent nibs, the past couple of years have been better from a QC perspective, at least as far as all of the #5 nibs I’ve tested go.

The nib in the Supra is a throwback to the bad old days. To me, this is 100% a Bock nib, with all of the inconsistencies that come along with that. The nib feels thin, which makes the tines flex, which leads to line inconsistency, and sometimes scratchiness. In short, typical Bock steel nib performance. I’m sure I can manipulate it into something better, but I’m not sure I will.

Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen Writing

There is a lot to like about the Supra, but if I were in Kaweco’s shoes I would break up the party and turn this into two pens. One would be in the short configuration - a Liliput XL or a Sport Supra - with similar metal materials in use. The second would be a more traditional long Supra, but with acrylic materials and no separate middle section.

I think Kaweco could fit a pen in their lineup that’s a step up from the Perkeo, and more fun than the Student, with a price point in the middle to match. How about a nice, long test tube-looking eye dropper?

Whatever they decide to do with the Supra - keep it as-is, reimagine it, or scrap it completely - the one choice they need to make is to apply the changes to their #5 nib manufacturing to their #6 nibs. That alone would make a world of difference in this pen.

At $135 for Stainless Steel, and $130 for Brass, I think the Kaweco Supra is fairly priced. In fact, if this pen only came in the short configuration I would happily pay that for what is essentially a Liliput XL. Anyone considering this pen will need to determine exactly how they will use it, and decide if the small issues will turn into major annoyances.

(The Pen Addict purchased this pen at a discount from Goldspot.)


Enjoy reading The Pen Addict? Then consider becoming a member to receive additional weekly content, giveaways, and discounts in The Pen Addict shop. Plus, you support me and the site directly, for which I am very grateful.

Membership starts at just $5/month, with a discounted annual option available. To find out more about membership click here and join us!

Kaweco Supra Stainless Steel Fountain Pen Line
Posted on July 13, 2020 and filed under Kaweco, Supra, Fountain Pens, Pen Reviews.

Esterbrook Camden Composition Fountain Pen Review

Esterbrook Camden Composition Fountain Pen Review

(Sarah Read is an author, editor, yarn artist, and pen/paper/ink addict. You can find more about her at her website and on Twitter. And check out her latest book, Out of Water, now available where books are sold!)

Stationery with a stylish nod to another type of stationery? That's a winning aesthetic. I still remember my first composition book, purchased for my high school biology class. I had always been tempted by those elite-looking books when school shopping, and I wanted one. They looked so much cooler than notebooks. I didn't want to just "note" things, I wanted to "compose" them. And I needed those marbled covers and cloth binding to do it, I was certain. I reveled in the use of that composition book--my biology labs were written up with the elaborate precision that would later manifest in my bullet journals. I still can't resist a good composition notebook, and I couldn't resist the Esterbrook Camden Composition Fountain Pen, either. I mean, look at it.

Esterbrook Camden Composition Fountain Pen

Full disclosure: this is my first Esterbrook of any kind. I've played with the vintage ones, but I've never owned one, an I haven't made any foray into the new brand until now. So I can't draw any comparisons under the Esterbrook name, but I can speak to its individual quality.

Esterbrook Camden Composition Fountain Pen Nib

I love this pen. Not just because it's stylish and nostalgic, but because it's an overall excellent pen. It has a metal body with a paint-spatter marble effect overlaid on it. The surface is slightly textured. It's weighty, but not heavy--it just feels sturdy, but is very comfortable to hold and is balanced enough to not cause hand fatigue. It doesn't post well, however--it's shallow, over-long, and unbalanced when posted. There is a springy clip on the cap. The cap is a twist closure, and has a "cushion closure" that feels bouncy as you close and open it. You have to press it in and then twist to close it, but this ensures a nice seal, so there is no nib dry-out.

Esterbrook Camden Composition Fountain Pen Open

The grip section is resin, according to some online specs, though it doesn't feel like resin. the texture feels almost like carbon fiber, though some places are saying aluminum. I'm betting it's brushed aluminum. It's very comfortable to hold, with a slight contour that prevents finger slipping. The threads are smooth, and while there's a step between the grip and body, it's not sharp or intrusive.

Esterbrook Camden Composition Fountain Pen Section

The nib is a #6 Schmidt steel nib, available in F, M, and B. It writes well, with a perfect balance of wetness and feedback. It's a very smooth writer, and the performance combined with the feel of the pen in the hand makes it a pen that I keep reaching for.

Esterbrook Camden Composition Fountain Pen Writing

The MSRP for this pen is $195, with most stores offering it for around $156. It's a very fair price. Right now it's available in Lime “Spring Break" Green, and “Back to School" Black, with promises of a fall red color coming in a few months. There are only 250 each of these limited-edition beauties, so I wouldn't wait, if you're as smitten as I am. The only downside? I don't know of any classic-looking composition books that have fountain pen friendly paper. If you know of one, please drop me a line!

(Kenro Industries provided this product at no charge to The Pen Addict for review purposes.)


Enjoy reading The Pen Addict? Then consider becoming a member to receive additional weekly content, giveaways, and discounts in The Pen Addict shop. Plus, you support me and the site directly, for which I am very grateful.

Membership starts at just $5/month, with a discounted annual option available. To find out more about membership click here and join us!

Esterbrook Camden Composition Fountain Pen Box
Posted on July 9, 2020 and filed under Esterbrook, Fountain Pens, Pen Reviews.