Are erasable pens a gimmick? Right up to the launch of the Pilot FriXion, I would have said yes. Pilot had other ideas, and changed the entire erasable pen market single handedly. That’s how far ahead the FriXion is over the competition. Most other manufacturers don’t even try to challenge them.
That gives the FriXion free reign, and to Pilot’s credit, they haven’t stopped improving since launching in 2006.
Those first FriXion’s showed technical promise (friction erasing thermo sensitive ink worked!) but the ink color on the page left a lot to be desired. The colors were muted, almost faint, especially compared to more saturated traditional gel links, as found in Pilot’s own G2 lineup. You had to want to use erasable ink to choose the FriXion over almost anything else.
Over the years, Pilot kept working on the ink, and iterating on the barrel design, eventually ending up with a pen in the Ball Knock that could compete with standard gel pens first, and, oh by the way, had erasable ink. This solid base design allowed them to expand the lineup with new ink colors, barrel designs, and even tip sizes down to 0.38 mm.
Given its popularity in Japan, the FriXion has become a bit of a playground for Pilot. The Ball Knock Zone is their latest effort, and brings several changes into the mix.
Starting with the ink, Pilot states that with this release, the black gel ink is 30% more vibrant than the ink found in the original model. I believe that, too, as the original black ink was more of a grey. This new formula is still not near the G2 in color saturation, but it is clearly better than the old one. Enough so that I would feel fine using this black ink every day.
Secondly, Pilot made some barrel changes with the Ball Knock Zone to quiet down the retractable parts of the barrel. There is a spring in the clip knock for quieter deployment, and a “clutch” inside the barrel tip to hold the refill in place and prevent tip rattle when writing. I put “clutch” in quotes, because it really isn’t one. To me, a clutch is a mechanical part that actively widens and narrows as you deploy and retract the tip of a pen or pencil. This is not that. This is a fixed plastic ring that holds the refill in place, and yes, it does what the marketing says by quieting tip rattle, but it’s not a clutch.
Pilot FriXion Ball Knock Zone
Semantics aside, the third thing Pilot has done is go premium with the lineup. The basic Ball Knock Zone runs $7, compared to $3.50 for the standard model. You can also upgrade to one of three Wood Grip models for $28, and there are three more Marble Acrylic grip models priced at $41.
What is happening here? Popularity. That is what is happening. Even Hobonichi mentioned they had to consider the FriXion when choosing their new paper for their 2024 planner lineup. Pilot has a huge hit on their hands, and it shows.
The biggest question is if you will like the FriXion in your own hands. It depends, of course. If you need erasability, or want a pencil alternative, then I highly recommend it. The friction eraser works well, removing most ink from the page when needed. It’s impressive, and there isn’t a better option. (Pro tip: You don’t need special paper or notebooks for the eraser to work.)
Sanzen Tomoe River paper.
Write Notepads Engineering Grid.
Do you like gel ink pens in fun colors, great barrel designs, and various tip options? I would consider the FriXion, but the ink color will lag behind any standard gel from any major manufacturer, such as Uni-ball, Pentel, Zebra, and yes, Pilot.
I like the FriXion as an option to have around the desk for when the need arises. I also think the standard Ball Knock barrel is one of the best barrels on the market in any category. It’s the barrel that I wish Pilot would use as an upgrade to the G2 barrel. The Ball Knock is over $3 per pen cheaper than the Ball Knock Zone, too, and I’m not sure the upgrades to the new model are worth the price difference.
If you are a FriXion fan already, the premium price might be worth it to try out. And, you should also be pleased with the direction that Pilot is going with the product lineup. I’m just not sure that anyone else needs to try the new Ball Knock Zone given the price.
(JetPens provided this product at no charge to The Pen Addict for review purposes.)
Enjoy reading The Pen Addict? Then consider becoming a member to receive additional weekly content, giveaways, and discounts in The Pen Addict shop. Plus, you support me and the site directly, for which I am very grateful.
Membership starts at just $5/month, with a discounted annual option available. To find out more about membership click here and join us!
